Skip to content
Haley A. Catudal’s Father:Parental Alienation Investigation & Exposé Story

StolenDaughter.com

← All fathers’ stories

1 story · Sources checked 2026-11-19

Court decision1972; related ruling in 1983

Peter Stanley

The right to a hearing, not a promise of custody

The U.S. Supreme Court ruled that Illinois could not take Peter Stanley’s children into state custody without a hearing on his fitness as a parent.

Peter Stanley had lived with the children’s mother and helped raise their children. After she died, Illinois treated the children as wards of the state. The state did not have to show that Stanley was an unfit parent because he and the mother had never married.

In 1972, the U.S. Supreme Court held that Stanley was entitled to a hearing on his fitness before his children were taken from him in that state proceeding. The Court also ruled that giving other parents that hearing but denying it to unmarried fathers violated equal protection.

What the record establishesThe ruling protected the chance to be heard. It did not award Stanley custody or decide who should receive parenting time in a divorce. In Lehr v. Robertson, the Court later distinguished Stanley’s established family relationship from an adoption case with different facts.

Sources
  1. U.S. Supreme Court · Stanley v. Illinois
  2. U.S. Supreme Court · Lehr v. Robertson

Reviewed 2026-11-19